Amelia, if only. Thank you so much to Harper Children’s Group for the advanced copy of this book. Becky Albertalli is a master of the young adult voice. Her collections of characters feels like an ode to queer joy and normalizing individual paths to coming out. Amelia and her group of friends are no exception. Immediately, I was drawn into the way Amelia‘s feelings and thoughts jump off the page. One of the things I appreciate most about the writing in this book is how well it captures the teenage voice. The roundabout way they get to the point, the way they joke with each other, the pauses, and the inflection; you can feel the emotions, even just from reading the words. The writing here is wonderful and reminded me of her previous books. I enjoyed the idea of parasocial relationships and the way we discuss content creators in the online spaces. Both teens and adults need to think about how we perceive others online and how we cannot truly know someone just from engaging with their content. I did struggle with this book, as I felt the central conflict did not become clear until 85% of the book. By then, I felt we did not have enough time to wrap it up. I enjoyed all of the “Reddit”-like threads, the incorporation of text messages, and the way this friend group loved each other. I thought the connections to Imogen, one of my previous favorite characters, were really well done and did not feel forced. Overall, I enjoyed this one. Imogen, obviously, will remain my go-to author for those looking to read this author. I would recommend this one to those looking for experiences of queer joy, bisexual acceptance, and stories about the transition between high school and college.
- Book Review
- Amelia, If Only
- Becky Albertalli
- June 29, 2025
Amelia, If Only
Related
READ VIA:
Thank you, Macmillan Audio, for the free advanced listening copy.
ABOUT:
When Joy Moore goes missing, Benny Abbot immediately spirals into panic. Joy is his best friend and podcast co-host, and there appears to be a decent strain in their relationship. Benny’s unease is compounded by the fact that Joy’s husband, Xander, is also missing. As the days pass, Benny becomes a subject himself. It is only through Joy’s POV that the truth begins to come to life.
MY THOUGHTS:
This is one heck of a debut. I love that this thriller also had this huge friendship/romance subplot. Genre-bending lovers, this is for you.
The writing is sharp, the pacing near perfect, and the reveals are shocking. Crum easily propels this narrative forward in a way that left me excited every time I picked this book up.
In particular, I enjoyed the feeling of not knowing whom to trust, and Crum did an excellent job of casting doubt in the reader’s mind about what was happening.
The dual timeline- dual POV helped feed my ever present suspense while also giving me enough information to keep me fully engaged!
Plus, the Los Angeles hills vibe was immaculate, which always makes me enjoy a book more!
AUDIO:
If you are an audiobook fan, you need to listen to this book. The production quality is through the roof. Whelan and Hopkins complement each other so well! I wanted this podcast to be real. The snippets we got were so excellent!
SIMILAR BOOKS:
This reminded me of None of This is True, but that might just be because it’s a podcast. This was (thankfully) a little less dark.
SHOULD YOU READ:
This Might Save Your Life will be a hit for fans of thrillers and contemporary fiction alike.
